First, there aren't a lot of properties in the area that cater to a group our size (10 total, 3 couples, 2 of which have 2 children). This property has a great location and is a great value relative to the other large places. Most of the interior has been tastefully redone.
I think we all agreed after the week that it was terrific and we'd be willing to come back to it. Some of the pluses:
+board games
+towels and linens were plentiful
+nice bathrooms
+nice outdoor entertaining space, great view
+in unit washer dryer was helpful
+TV/internet all worked seamlessly
+check in was easy / owner was reachable
+kitchen fully appointed for cooking, plus the grill outdoors
+location to Madawaska, Canada, Sinclair for shopping, entertainment, boat/ATV rentals.
+close to the trail head for ATVs, nice scenic overlook about a 5 minute ride
+tennis/pickleball court 6 minute drive away
There are definitely some niggles like sticky doors, thin curtains, firepit seems to be a work in progress, but no deal breakers, and knowing those, we'd still come back.