Search Guest Houses in Tarpum Bay

"My wife and I stayed at Blue Turtle Cottage for two weeks as our honeymoon and we loved our time in Eleuthera. The beach in front of the house was absolutely beautiful with pink sand and crystal clear blue water. There are some rocks in front of the house that are partially submerged but we enjoyed them because they created a long tidepool that was perfect for swimming and using as a lazy river, and also broke any waves that were coming off the Atlantic. Make sure you follow Linda's instructions about taking the trash as much as you can and not leaving ANY food out to avoid attracting flies. The backup generator is a huge plus as well since there are frequent power outages on the Island. It came on automatically and we were never without power for more than a moment. We had an issue with the condensation drains on the air conditioners being clogged and leaking, but Linda and her property managers replied fast and had the issue fixed as soon as possible. Linda was great to work with and answered any questions we had about the island. We would absolutely recommend staying at the Blue Turtle Cottage, as it is perfect for two people and the beach is incredible."

"The cottage was exactly as we expected and more! We were totally relaxed for our entire stay. We did suggest an upgrade to their 2 beach chairs and the Conch’d Out team were already looking, very nice! We did have a “water issue” but with the help of Anne and the caretaker it was resolved quickly. We have already booked for next year, but for a longer time. We love the privacy!! We are total beach people and this fit us beyond belief! Our” secret hideaway”:)"

"This property is amazing and we had NO disappointments! The beds were comfortable and felt like home versus a hotel bed. The kitchen had almost every appliance you could want to help prep meals. The Screenroom was our favorite place to take our meals. We spent most of our week kayaking and snorkeling off the beach outside the house. There is so much wildlife right in the water right off the shore. We will cherish this trip and hope to return to Parlay at Sunset!"

"Had an amazing time at Tradewinds. Great location. Plenty of space to spread out. Everything we needed was there, and Tippy’s was right down the road. Communication with Jethro was excellent. The pool was an added bonus after along day exploring beaches."

"Loved our stay at Senza Nome! Steps away from the ocean and the view from the porch was fabulous! Enjoyed chilling on the porch listening to the ocean. The beach cottage was adorable. The property manager was wonderful…..she had the internet up and running a few minutes after we arrived. Definitely planning to return."

"The nicest most friendly hosts in a lovely room with all the amenities. So grateful to them. I wholeheartedly recommend you come and enjoy a stay here."

"enjoyed staying in Garden of Light; the beach is gorgeous and almost always private; great communication with the host"

"Property is exactly as shown. Star of the show is it's location relative all the wonderful beaches (Twin Coves, French Leave, Cocodimama, Navy Base Beach, 10 Bay Beach). Incredible how you essentially will have your own private run of these amazing white sand beaches. Saw Dolphins, Starfish, Rays, Turtles, Sharks - and each day was a new adventure (with hardly a soul to be seen on the beach). Then you have the pool to enjoy to end the day. People are friendly. Close to town (learned the last day to take cash down to the pier around 2 or 3 in the afternoon to buy fresh fish - will remember for next time). If you are looking for a resort or party - go to Baha Mar, Atlantis, or Margaritaville... If you want quiet - go to the Family Islands. Eleuthera has forever ruined beaches for my family. Simply stunning. We will be back - almost cringe telling others as it's a wonderful secret that nobody seems to know about. Sunscreen needed, we brought some essentials from back home for our 5 year old, and the bugs come out at sunrise and sunset (not during the day). Power went out once - property manager replied quickly and it was a flip of a button on the Generac."

"What an amazing property!! We absolutely loved everything about this area, condo, and host. The sunrise views and beach were simply spectacular and the host was wonderful to work with."